Journal of Iranian Medical Council

Journal of Iranian Medical Council

Investigating the Motivations of Mothers to Volunteer for Gestational Surrogacy: A Systematic Review Study

Document Type : Review article

Authors
1 Community Health Research Center, Isfahan City ( Isf.C.,) Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
2 Department of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law, Hazrat-e- Masoumeh University, Qom, Iran
Abstract
Abstract
A surrogate mother is a woman who becomes pregnant and gives birth to a child with the intention of donating the child to another person or couple. Surrogacy has become a new ethical challenge. Various factors such as economic issues, social stigma, consequences of pregnancy and the commercialization of this issue play a big role in the acceptance of surrogacy. The aim of the study was to investigate the motivations effective in accepting surrogacy by volunteer women. The keywords of “surrogate, motivation, volunteer, gestational, infertility” were searched for in studies published between 1970 and 2023 in reliable databases, resulting in 130 articles, of which 58 articles were reviewed. This review article searched for studies published by researchers from 1970 to 2023 in Scopus, PubMed, ScienceDirect, Google Scholar, as well as other jurisprudential texts using alternative keywords. Financial need and independence, social factors, the process of psychological compensation and restorative motives, resolving loneliness due to previous failures, resolving the internal psychological conflicts and compensatory movement, unresolved unconscious feelings, interest in experiencing a different type of motherhood (attachment or curiosity), empathy, altruism and spiritualism (commitment and care) are among the effective factors in surrogacy volunteering. The lack of supporting regulations for surrogate mothers and biological parents causes the profiteering of middlemen and commercial agencies. It is necessary to review the relevant laws in order to preserve human dignity and prevent the vulnerability of the surrogate.

Keywords

Subjects


Abstract
A surrogate mother is a woman who becomes pregnant and gives birth to a child with the intention of donating the child to another person or couple. Surrogacy has become a new ethical challenge. Various factors such as economic issues, social stigma, consequences of pregnancy and the commercialization of this issue play a big role in the acceptance of surrogacy. The aim of the study was to investigate the motivations effective in accepting surrogacy by volunteer women. The keywords of “surrogate, motivation, volunteer, gestational, infertility” were searched for in studies published between 1970 and 2023 in reliable databases, resulting in 130 articles, of which 58 articles were reviewed. This review article searched for studies published by researchers from 1970 to 2023 in Scopus, PubMed, ScienceDirect, Google Scholar, as well as other jurisprudential texts using alternative keywords. Financial need and independence, social factors, the process of psychological compensation and restorative motives, resolving loneliness due to previous failures, resolving the internal psychological conflicts and compensatory movement, unresolved unconscious feelings, interest in experiencing a different type of motherhood (attachment or curiosity), empathy, altruism and spiritualism (commitment and care) are among the effective factors in surrogacy volunteering. The lack of supporting regulations for surrogate mothers and biological parents causes the profiteering of middlemen and commercial agencies. It is necessary to review the relevant laws in order to preserve human dignity and prevent the vulnerability of the surrogate.
Keywords: Infertility, Islam, Gestational, Motivation, Surrogate, Volunteer  

Introduction
The importance of fertility and infertility in Iran and other societies
Infertility is a common problem that affects about 10-15% of couples (1). According to the statistics of the World Health Organization, around 60-80 million couples worldwide suffer from infertility (2). Infertility or childlessness is also a neglected global fertility issue for both sexes. It has been reported that 70 million couples are suffering from infertility worldwide and are increasing (3). The prevalence of infertility varies in different parts of Iran, but it is close to global statistics (4). A total of five systematic reviews (n=279717 women) were published between 2012 and 2023. Based on the existing literature, the prevalence of infertility in Iran (1990-2019) is 13.2% (ranged: 7.8-13.2%), while primary infertility is 10.6% (ranged: 3.09-18.3%), and secondary infertility is 3.2% (ranged: 2-3.2%) (5). Fertility is very valuable in most cultures and is part of women’s power and identity, thus the desire to have children is one of the most essential human incentives in life (6). Religious and cultural norms and values reinforce fertility, which is why Muslim countries can be described as family-centered societies in which marriage and childbearing are of great value (7). As Islam encourages fertility, it also supports infertility treatment and protects children necessitating care of pregnant women and children’s health. Supporting the application of infertility techniques requires the preservation of ancestry. Every newborn baby must have a specific parent and communicate with them (8). 
Birth of the baby can strengthen the foundation of the family, enhance the emotional needs of individuals, and ultimately lead to the continuation of the generation, and infertility is a reality that is incompatible with all of these. Therefore, in the list of 86 materials of stressful events, infertility is one of the most negative events that lead to the death of a child or spouse (9). In the Holy Quran, it has been encouraged to be a child in various verses (51-53 of Surah Al-Hijr). In other verses, the child is referred to as a divine blessing (72 of Surah an-Nahl), the ornament of life (46 of Surah Al-Kahf) etc. In addition to the words of many of the religious leaders, paying attention to the practice of the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) in having children is also a clear proof that the increase in generations is acceptable among the Muslim societies. Infertility causes frustration, stress, anxiety and depression in the life of couples (10). In many families, infertility with different causes (male, female or both) can lead to stressful experiences and serious psychological problems (11,12).

The importance of infertility techniques including surrogacy
With new developments and many efforts, medical science has succeeded in treating infertility using different techniques, one of which is “surrogate mother” (13,14). Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) techniques, such as IVF and embryo freezing, were first adopted in the field of infertility treatment in Europe and the United States, and spread throughout the world in the 1980s. Then, changes have been made in IVF and ICSI, egg donation, surrogate uterus, genetic diagnosis before implantation and egg freezing (15). A surrogate mother is a woman who becomes pregnant and gives birth to a child with the intention of donating the child to another person or couple. 
The use of surrogates in the treatment of infertility and pregnancy through IVF is used in women with special conditions such as: lack of uterus, uterine abnormalities, serious medical problems with prohibition of pregnancy and homosexual couples (16). Herweck et al’s study on international gestational surrogacy cycles in the United States (US) showed that of 40,177 embryo transfers to a gestational carrier from 2014 to 2020, parents’ gestational carrier cycles increased each year from 2014 (n=2758, 22.0%) to 2019 (n=4905, 39.8%) with a decrease in 2020 (n=4713, 31.8%) (17). In the United States, the legal status of surrogacy varies greatly from state to state. Some states (e.g., California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Texas) apply friendly provisions and make GS contracts enforceable, while others (e.g., New York, Michigan, Utah) restrict the practice; and under some conditions, they may criminalize GS contracts (18). Surrogacy process is illegal in countries such as Germany and Sweden, and there are special laws in countries such as France, the Netherlands, Denmark, Australia and some states of the US (19).
Surrogate mothers in Iran-Islamic Bioethics Perspectives
Surrogacy is one of the new issues of jurisprudence that has raised due to the progress of medical science, therefore there is no Quranic verse or hadiths in this regard, and thus no fatwa has been issued in this field by the jurists of the past era. Contemporary jurists, including Ayatollah Khamenei, Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi and Ayatollah Khoei, have ruled on the permissibility of this issue and they do not have much difference in this regard. Only a few jurists, including Ayatollah Tabrizi and Ayatollah Fazel Lankarani, have ruled that it is not permissible. Iran is the only Islamic country where embryo donation and surrogacy programs are carried out. These plans have been accepted and approved by rulings of clerical scholars (20,21). However, Sunni Muslim scholars consider the use of surrogacy illegal and oppose its implementation. One of their arguments is that a surrogate is a clear form of using a donated sperm from a foreigner (someone out of the marriage contract), in a woman’s womb, which leads to mixing of ancestry. Mufti Sheikh Ahmad Kuti, an Islamic scholar, believes that introducing a man’s sperm into the womb of a woman who is not married to him violates God’s limits (22). According to the interpretation of “transgressing God’s limits”, he refers to the verses of the Qur’an (verses 5-7 of Surah Al-Mu’minun).
Those who protect their chastity. Except from their spouses, or their dependents—then they are free from blame. And those who are faithful to their trusts and pledges (Surah Al-Mu’minun: 5-7).

Surrogacy can be done in two ways
Traditional surrogate uterus (genetic/partial/direct) of the surrogate mother’s egg with the sperm of the legal father artificially inseminated and these two will be the genetic parents of the future baby.
Gestational surrogacy (host/full surrogate) in which an embryo is transferred from the intended parents or from a donated egg or sperm into the surrogate, the woman carrying the child has no genetic connection to the child (23,24). Surrogacy may be commercial or altruistic. If the surrogate mother receives money for the contract of surrogacy, it is considered commercial, and if she does not receive compensation other than the reimbursement of medical expenses and other expenses related to pregnancy and insurance coverage, it is called altruistic (25). In Iran, since 2001, surrogacy was offered to couples as one of the infertility treatment methods (26). Nowadays, infertility clinics are active in Tehran and also in some big cities such as Isfahan, Shiraz, Tabriz, Mashhad and Yazd. Inside Iran, following the government’s latest pronatalist policies, assisted reproductive technologies are recognized as a tool to help the government realize its population growth policies (27). Choosing a surrogate mother plays a very important role in the treatment success. The person chosen as a surrogate mother can be a family member or an unknown and unrelated person. The surrogate mother must have discretion in all stages of pregnancy and her decision must be respected even if it is against the interests of the requesting couple (28). On the other hand, Dadkhah et al’s research has shown that surrogate mothers are generally from the weakest social strata and head of the household. They generally play a passive role in the relationships that govern the production of children and they are treated as a vessel carrying the fetus (29). 
In other studies, the motivations of the people under study were stated in two groups: Most of these people considered financial need as their main motivation in carrying others’ fetus. Some are motivated by helping their friends or relatives whose uterus is not capable of carrying and keeping the fetus due to some reasons (30,31). In the study conducted by Berend et al, surrogate mothers define surrogacy as a “labor of love”. Women often describe their surrogacy as a “shared love journey”. They hope for a lasting relationship with the couple they carry for them. Altruistic love and forgiveness are compatible with close interpersonal relationships rather than the profit market. Surrogates are appreciated and supported in their community, where they agree that giving life is a moral good. This position has contributed to the desire to have children again for others (32). Regarding the issue of surrogacy, various legal issues, social and cultural dimensions have been investigated, but the reasons and motivations of women volunteering for surrogate motherhood are limited and need further investigation.
Objective: This study was conducted with the aim of investigating the factors and motivations affecting the acceptance of surrogacy by volunteer women.

Materials and Methods
Protocol of survey
This review article was conducted from April to December 2023 in order to investigate the factors and motivations influencing the acceptance of surrogacy by volunteer women based on PRISMA flow-chart for better evaluation.

Information of data sources 
In this review, related articles were searched for in domestic and foreign scientific databases among studies published from 1970 to 2022 in Scopus, PubMed, Science Direct, Google scholar, Magiran, SID and Iran Medex databases and other jurisprudential texts using the keywords of motivation, surrogate mother, and rules.
Eligibility criteria for selecting and evaluating the quality of articles
First, articles having the keywords published from 1970 to 2023 on surrogate mother motivations were read. Then, the classification of motivations in the field of surrogacy was discussed. In this review, 58 articles extracted from 130 articles on infertility and the motivation of surrogate mothers were examined (Figure 1). If there were multiple reports of a study, the most complete one was considered. Also, other exclusion criteria were irrelevant research studies, insufficient data in the research, lack of access to the full text of articles and editorial studies.

Study selection and data collection process
To collect the data, first, articles that had one of the above keywords alone or in combination in the title or text were selected. Based on the inclusion criteria, abstracts of the articles published in Persian and English were studied. After removing the articles that did not meet the inclusion criteria, the full-text of all the eligible articles was studied. Then, their results were extracted according to the investigated factor and given to another researcher for review and correction. In total, out of 130 articles, 58 articles were selected and analyzed.

Results
In this study, related findings in the field of investigating surrogate mother’s motivations include the following: economic and social factors, psychological compensation process and restorative motivations, resolving loneliness due to previous failures, solving internal psychological conflicts, interest in experiencing a different type of motherhood (attachment or curiosity), empathy-altruism and spirituality (commitment and care) (Figure 2, Tables 1 and 2).

Table 1. A summary of the research background of articles from other countries about the motivation of surrogate mothers

The conclusion/key message of the research

Title

Main method

The author

year/ reference

Surrogacy is defined  as a “labor of love”. Women often

describe their surrogacy as a “journey” of shared love.

They hope for a lasting relationship with the couple they

carry for. Love is honorable and noble. Surrogates are

appreciated and supported in their community

The romance of surrogacy. Sociological forum

Original research article

Zsuzsa Berend (2012)

(32)

Empirical data suggest that surrogates value maintaining

their personal identity as “mother” to their children,

while distancing themselves from this title in relation to the surrogate. Also becoming a surrogate mother is an

answer to personal crises, such as the illness or death

of a parent, or a recent divorce. They feel an

“existential void” that drives them to a surrogacy with

the goal of “self-fulfillment” or “filling their lives with

something meaningful”.  The feeling of loneliness and

isolation leads them to choosing surrogacy in order

to create satisfactory social relationships

The social construction of surrogacy research: an anthropological critique of the psychosocial scholarship on surrogate motherhood

Review article

Teman E. (2008)

(33)

In order to reduce the stigmatization of women, a

regulatory policy is needed that takes into account the

complex understanding of surrogacy and perceptions of

surrogate mothers in Indian society. Also, based on the

attitude of some women, their actions have brought

peace and tranquility to families that were suffering from

chaos and violence due to childlessness

Surrogate mother-praiseworthy or stigmatized: a qualitative study on perceptions of surrogacy in Assam, India

Individual interviews and focus group discussions

Arvidsson et al (2017)

(35)

This study illustrates the sense-making process that characterizes the experience of leaving gestational surrogates in commercial surrogacy. First, the findings of this study emphasize the importance of prenatal pregnancy counseling, which necessitates not only a legal but also a psychological contract between surrogate mothers and intended couples. Second, the ability of gestational surrogates to manage their identity during and after the surrogacy process has been demonstrated

Mothers for others: an interpretative phenomenological analysis of gestational surrogates’ child relinquishment experiences

Qualitative

method, embracing a phenomenological-hermeneutic research design

Ferolino

et al (2020)

(36)

Based on the results of this study, an equal number of respondents accepted or rejected the idea of surrogacy. Age and job status were among the factors that had no significant difference in accepting this attitude. But education was an effective factor. Almost 43% of them had high school education and approved surrogacy. A large number of people with primary or lower education were not confident in using surrogacy. In addition, marital status also had an effect on people’s attitude towards surrogacy. 46% of single people and 30% of married people rejected the offer of succession. It was concluded from this study that people need better information about surrogacy and donation

Assisted reproductive technologies and the Iranian community

attitude towards infertility

Descriptive

study

through cluster sampling

Aliyar Ahmadi & Sara Bamdad (2017)

(37)

This study showed that the factors that cause the referral of surrogates to clinics are as follows. Many of them had a very low socio-economic background, little or no formal education, and their main motivation was financial compensation and poverty reduction. The husband’s role in succession varies from indifference to insisting on the wife’s succession. Many Indians compare surrogacy to having sex. Therefore, due to lack of support from community members and fear of disapproval, some are forced to move to another place. Although many other systems support women who are trying to succeed, it is necessary to understand more about the level of satisfaction of these women

Economic necessity or noble cause?

A qualitative study exploring motivations for gestational surrogacy in gujarat, India

Qualitative

study and

interview

Sharvari Karandikar

(2014)

(38)

The results showed that most surrogates were satisfied

with their relationship and reported positive experiences,

and few differences were found based on the type of

surrogacy. The primary motive was to help couples to

have children. Most of them had no problems with their

mental health

The long-term experiences of surrogates: relationships and contact with surrogacy families in genetic and gestational surrogacy arrangements

Qualitative study and semi-structured interviews

Susan Imrie (2014)

(39)

Research shows positive adaptation to the process and benefits for triad members (people involved in surrogacy). Altruism is the main motivation of surrogates. Most surrogates feel valued and successful after this process. It also increases their self-esteem. Few of them mentioned financial gain as their main motivation. This process has a high positive psychological effect on people who become parents through surrogacy compared to those who have children through donated eggs or the natural process of conception. It is necessary to create evaluation strategies, prevent problems, conduct scientific studies and implement strategies for psycho-social interventions

Gestational surrogacy: psychosocial

aspects

Review article

Nicolás Ruiz-Robledillo (2016)

(40)

Surrogates may say that they have no expectations from this relationship and that each relationship has a point. They acknowledge that they have no expectation of this communication, but expect that this communication will be maintained after succession, even if it is by periodic email. Surrogacy is often a combination of a contract and a gift relationship, and this gift relationship does not end when the contract is completed. Surrogates also believe that surrogacy creates a bond that does not dissolve after payment. The feeling of gratitude and friendship is the best reward for couples. Also, disconnection and lack of communication causes disappointment in the successor

The social context for surrogates’ motivations and satisfaction

 

Review article

Zsuzsa Berend (2014)

(41)

In the United States, poor women of color are often perceived as working as surrogates, and surrogacy is portrayed as a form of extreme injustice. Also, the surrogacy market exposes women to vulnerability. American women who work as surrogates are at the lowest income level. Also, they do not have financial or educational resources, and this leads them to exploitation and abuse by the rich. As a result, poor women are exposed to exploitation through surrogacy

Surrogacy has been one of the most rewarding experiences in my life. A content analysis of blogs by u.s commercial gestational surrogates

Using interpretive phenomenological analysis for the methodological approach of research

Nicole F. Bromfield

(2016)

(42)

According to this review, surrogates viewed surrogacy as a mission where they have to overcome many obstacles (such as screening, waiting time and IVF method) to prove their strength.

In this way, surrogates realize that they are building a life while their economic status is rarely changed through surrogacy. This mission gave them the opportunity to help the nation and feel that they are a part of God’s creation

The surrogate

body and

the pregnant self

Review article

Elly Teman (2010)

(43)

Motivations for travel including legal and religious prohibitions; resource considerations; lack of access to gametes and reproductive aids, quality and safety concerns; Personal preferences, higher risks for mothers and children are associated with multiple embryo transfers, multiple and older pregnancies, and higher average age of women fulfilling the fertility journey

Globalised quests

for assisted conception: reproductive travel for infertility and involuntary childlessness

Synthesis findings from our own empirical research and in addition to a review of clinical, ethical, legal, and

regulatory complexities

Andrea Whittaker et al (2019)

(44)

Involuntary childlessness is a global phenomenon that has negative effects on the couple or family involved. Women suffering from involuntary childlessness are faced with many problems, which included: experiences of marital turmoil, psychological torture, feelings of discomfort and sadness, failure to meet maternal expectations, financial limitations for treatment, and a feeling of lack of social support, so there is a need to screen women for the above causes

Women’s experiences of living with involuntary childlessness in Uganda: a qualitative phenomenological study

Qualitative phenomenological approach

Susan Asiimwe (2022)

(45)

Childlessness has financial, emotional and relational consequences for many people. While counseling has been reported to be beneficial in this group of women. Infertile women experienced high levels of distress, with 42% sometimes experiencing suicidal feelings. Those who were most at risk for distress and suicidal feelings had experienced unsuccessful treatment outcomes

Experiences of involuntary childlessness and treatment in the UK: what has changed in 20 years?

Online survey

Nicola Payne et al

(2021)

(46)

A large number of women (68 percent) had a major role in deciding and convincing their husbands to participate in surrogacy. 17% of the experienced women, both (husband and wife) were willing and trying to participate in this process, and 15% of the women applicants were more insistent than their husbands. Few of them were against their husbands for the following reasons. These women stated that in public gatherings, the practice of surrogacy means selling a child, or being a sex worker, and is considered as an immoral and stigmatizing work. This factor causes their spouses to resist this issue. They consider it stigma and rape. Because of that, women have been absent from their families for a long time

Women’s control

over decision to participate

in surrogacy

Ethnographic and qualitative study through interviews, stratified purposive sampling

Asmita Naik Africawala (2019)

(47)

This study showed that it is not easy to understand the motives of surrogate mothers. Empirical debates often bring up exploitation. The reason is that the surrogate person is financially needy and desperate. Therefore, she is exploited and turns to surrogacy as a financial-economic resource. The results showed that financial problems are the cause of this disappointing action

Surrogate mothers: an exploration of the

empirical and the normative

Review article

Lina Peng (2013)

(48)

 

Table 2. A summary of the research background of articles in Persian about the motivation of surrogate mothers

The author/year

references

Main method

Title

The conclusion/key message of the research

Garmaroudi Shirin,

2008

(30)

Qualitative study, holistic view, participatory observation and the use of ethnographic methods

Gestational Surrogacy in Iran

Surrogate mothers expressed their motivation in religious and moral frameworks, as well as achieving their goals, such as strengthening the sense of altruism, financial benefit, gift exchange, childbirth and childbearing

Fazli Khalaf et al (2oo8)

(49)

Review article

 

Psychological aspects of surrogate pregnancy in host women

The surrogacy is a positive experience for women, and in most cases, they do it with the motivation of helping a couple who cannot have children, and for reasons of friendship and a sense of worth. However, this method faces many psychological and social challenges. It is recommended that the use of surrogacy be considered as a risky psychological experience, and that both parties should be closely monitored, and specialist consultations should be carried out before, during and after pregnancy

Dadkhah

et al  (2020)

(50)

Qualitative using phenomenological method

Surrogacy culture in Iranian society in Tehran

Surrogate mothers are generally from the weakest sections of the society and have financial motivations. Most of these women are heads of households. They generally play a passive role in the relations governing child production. They are treated as a commodity/object or a container carrying an embryo

Monir Pashmi MA

(2010)

(51)

Analytical-descriptive

and

causal-comparative

Evaluating the experiences of surrogate and intended mothers in terms of surrogacy in Isfahan

The results of the study showed that the surrogate and applicant mothers were completely different in terms of socio-cultural situation. But their psychological characteristics did not differ significantly. Also, most surrogate mothers and mothers applying for surrogacy do not consider it a problem. Both sides of this contract were satisfied and had a good relationship with each other during pregnancy, but after giving birth, these mothers do not intend to continue their relationship

Mitra Zandi (2014)

(52)

Qualitative design

with approach

conventional

content analysis

Nine centuries waiting: the experiences of Iranians surrogacy commissioning mothers

Two main issues of cultural dilemma and uncertain expectation were obtained from the data analysis of this study. Each of which included three sub-themes. A: Cultural problem including (1- Social taboo 2- Worry about disclosing information to others and the child 3- Worry about changing the identity of mother and child. B: Uncertain expectation also includes 1- Worry about the health of the fetus and surrogate mother 2- Worry Regarding an unfamiliar surrogate 3-concern about not being prepared for the role

of mother. The results of this study revealed the importance of emotional care of surrogate mothers by nurses and health care providers

Parvin Dashtizadeh

(2019)

(26)

Descriptive-analytical using documentary method and

through evaluation of books, articles, the opinions of the

same judicial record

and valid judicial procedures

Legal and ethical challenges of surrogacy

contracts termination in Iranian Healthcare system

Based on the results of this study, the absence of any written and coherent legal code has caused countless challenges in the legal and ethical fields of contracts. The economic need of the surrogate mother and the large number of children by infertile women provide the conditions for the exploitation of contractors and commercialization.

As a result, the legal and ethical challenges of surrogacy increase, and in some circumstances, the surrogate mother, genetic parents or treatment center may change their opinions and lead to abandoning this practice

Farzaneh Golboni (2020)

(53)

Qualitative

research with

grounded theory approach

Iranian model of decision making to use surrogacy: a grounded theory study

The results showed that effective factors include

not having children, being sensitive to the loss of parents, inability to reproduce, attitude and interaction in the family, perceived norms in the family, its customs, challenges and social status, hope for having the role of parents, trying to have children, hope and fear of choosing a surrogate, mutual support between couples, decision to use a surrogate, avoiding family pressure and legal measures

for using a surrogate. Among these variables, the main factor is hope for having the role of a parent, which is very effective as a concept that interacts with other concepts

to create motivation

Zahra Ghane-Mokhalle-souni

(2022)

(54)

Qualitative research

that uses a phenomenological approach

Representation of a ‘positive experience’ of surrogacy in Yazd, Iran: a qualitative study

Surrogate mothers experience conflicting feelings of inner satisfaction and social stigma during surrogacy. In the interview, some of them were willing to accept surrogacy, but they were afraid of the label and social stigma. Also, the findings showed that despite the existence of physical, social and cultural violence, experiences such as social stigma, the participants had an inner feeling of satisfaction and a positive view of their actions. It was female sacrifice and positive reward that caused happiness, the transmission of maternal feelings, good delivery, family acceptance and halal result. In fact, the lack of knowledge of the surrounding people about surrogacy causes misunderstanding of the surrounding people and dissatisfaction from the family and society

Mina Shayestefar (2017)

(55)

Qualitative research

that uses a phenomenological approach

Leading factors

to surrogacy

from pregnant surrogate

mothers’ vantage point: a

qualitative

research

Effective factors in the acceptance of surrogacy were defined in 7 sub-topics. These factors include life history, failures and fruitless efforts to improve life, economic independence, independence, altruism, forced acceptance of new conditions, atonement for sin and deal with God. Finally, these seven sub-topics were merged with each other and the main factors influencing the replacement

were created. The conclusion of this study was that the health care system in Iran should be strengthened. Abandoned women should be covered by insurance

so that they do not have to donate eggs and use surrogates several times. Because it causes damage to these women and human dignity

Mahmoodian H (2017)

(56)

Descriptive-analytical study

Attitudes of infertile women towards surrogacy in infertility clinics

of shiraz university of medical sciences

The results of the study showed that 72.5% of infertile women have a negative attitude towards surrogacy and the rest had a positive attitude. In fact, the main cause of women’s negative attitude was related to their abuse. This method is contrary to culture and religion. It also causes potential harassment and threats to surrogate mothers in relation to their husbands and his behavior with women and reduces the sense of belonging to the child

Sanaz Musavi (2020)

(57)

A systematic review and meta-analysis

Infertile women’s opinion concerning gestational surrogacy: a systematic review and meta-analysis

In this systematic review and meta-analysis,

the results showed that the rate of acceptance of

surrogacy in Iran is low, and the overall rate of positive attitude for accepting surrogacy in Iran is 39%. Therefore, politicians and decision makers should review and

revise the laws related to the presence of a third person

in a pregnancy in the issue of infertility

Fatemeh Hadizadeh-Talasaz (2015)

(58)

A large-scale exploratory and qualitative study focusing on the decision-making process regarding the choice of donor assisted reproductive methods

Decision for disclosure: the experiences of Iranian infertile couples undergoing assisted reproductive donation procedures

Based on this study, 32 patients were candidates for

using donated eggs, donated embryos or surrogates. In

the interviews conducted and the qualitative content analysis of the couples’ decisions, the general theme

was the experience of uncertainty about disclosing information to others and the main reason for

concealment is the concern about social issues,

negative views towards assisted reproductive methods

and lack of support for couples from family and friends.

As a result, it causes mental pressure for them when using these methods

Financial need and economic independence:
A common assumption in psychosocial research is that if female surrogates are typical, then what conditions lead to the unusual selection of surrogates? A strong reason for this choice may be the financial problem. Almost every study of the surrogate’s motivations looks for sufficient financial hardship in the surrogate’s life. If the surrogate mother has no financial problems, she tries to have a family relationship with the intended parents, which can justify her altruistic motives (33). 
Some studies mentioned surrogacy as a way to avoid financial hardship, have more financial desires, meet severe financial needs, provide the necessities of life, and create a spirit of independence. Also, the financial and economic failures of the spouse may create tense living conditions and a chaotic social situation, therefore these women are forced to engage in various economic activities, including surrogate motherhood. By replacing the mother, these women can improve their living conditions and start a new life (54) in exchange for paying the cost of pregnancy, which includes months of physical conflict and transferring a baby from one woman’s womb to another woman’s arms, which is actually a basic exchange in intimacy. Physical and emotional dependencies and interdependencies are well documented in empirical sociological reports (34). Other surveys demonstrate that most surrogate mothers were poor women who were salespeople, elderly nurses, and even domestic servants, and as surrogate mothers gained various physical and psychological experiences in this field.
Khalaf et al state that handing over the fetus to the couple who owns the baby after delivery may cause anxiety in surrogate mothers and cause psychological problems. Delivering the baby after delivery exposes them to the risk of postpartum depression and feelings of anger and guilt. On the other hand, female surrogate mothers might do this without knowing the various aspects of the issue due to the financial need for the agreed amount to be paid by the couple who owns the baby (49). The study of Dadkhah et al in Iran indicated that surrogate women are generally from the lower social classes and head of the household. It is also possible that surrogate mothers have faced failures and irreparable damages in the society and personal life. This failure is either financial and economical, or biological and social, and they have had a stressful life. After a long time, these women can see the good side of life again and start a new life. Of course, this situation has led to the emergence and confrontation of two opposing worlds. These women in low-income environments may be exploited (29). There is a global discourse on surrogacy in some countries, such as India, which originates from a western perspective and sees surrogacy as the exploitation of women in low-income environments that poverty drives them to become surrogate mothers. The local perspective on surrogacy in India is complex. Majority of people consider paying a surrogate against social norms. The surrogate mother is also often judged morally, either as a “bad mother” for selling her child, or as a “noble woman” who has helped a childless couple and is compensated for her selfless act and service (59). By 2026, the surrogacy business will become one of the most profitable revenue-generating services. Surrogacy has become a booming business in several states of the United States of America, Canada, and Israel, where the use of surrogacy is allowed (60).

Social factors
The surrogacy is the union of science, society and service, made into a reality by the individual. Surrogacy results in a win-win situation for both the infertile couple and the surrogate mother. The infertile couple can fulfill their most important wish and the surrogate mother receives the appropriate reward. For example, in some countries such as India, infertility is known as a social stigma. Mental agony and trauma caused by infertility are strongly felt by the infertile couple. In fact, the factor that causes the individual and the society to show a great desire towards this issue is to eliminate the social stigma of infertility, and doing this is valuable for the society as well. This woman is known as a model woman in the society (61). Bhadaraka reports that the majority of Indian society saw the surrogate mother as a mixture of religion, culture, and science who followed noble services: (1) she showed a strong desire for society by doing something new, (2) she removed the stigma of infertility, (3) she performed her duty by doing something valuable for the society, and (4) she is an example of a model woman in the society (62). Another important social dimension is that the surrogate mother may be exposed to the risk of emotional suffering, but accepting the issue of surrogacy makes her worthy of respect and attention. According to the attitude of some women, their action has caused peace and serenity in families that were suffering from disorder and violence caused by childlessness (40). 
Another point is that surrogate pregnancy, even though it is altruistic, should be considered as a risky psychological experience. There are at least three psychological, social and physical challenges for each party. The risk of birth complications, medical risks, the relationship of surrogate mothers with the social context during pregnancy and delivery, and a close bond established between surrogate mother and the baby during pregnancy may increase the risk of depression and postpartum emotions, since this important bond cannot be easily eliminated. The study conducted in England by Jadva revealed that 32% of the surrogate mothers had emotional and psychological problems for several weeks after delivery (63). Even after the birth of the baby, surrogate mothers were extremely disappointed due to the loss of contact with the baby. They state that from the point of view of human rights, it is impossible not to expect complete lack of communication with the parent and baby couple (11).

The process of mental compensation and reparative motive
Resolving loneliness due to previous failures is one of the dimensions of the psychological aspect. Some women may not have family support, or they may be unhappy with their husbands and have had an unsuccessful married life. In order to eliminate loneliness, not to be far from the community and family, and to remove the loneliness gap, surrogacy appears as an opportunity and they step forward in this process. The choice of surrogacy is the answer to a personal crisis, such as illness, death of parents, or recent divorce. A sense of “existential emptiness” leads them toward surrogacy with the goal of “self-fulfillment” or “filling their lives with something meaningful”. Sometimes the feeling of loneliness and isolation leads them to choose surrogacy in order to create satisfactory social relationships (33). Some research has also shown that solving internal psychological conflicts and compensatory movement may be another motivation for women. Some researchers explicitly reject monetary motivation and try to look for “real” reasons for accepting surrogacy in events such as tragic losses or abuse in the surrogate’s past as a compensatory move. For instance, the search for unfortunate events in childhood, life history, personal relationships of the surrogate, life events related to the reproductive process such as pregnancy loss, abortion, divorce or death in the family can be investigated (64). Some researchers believe that accepting a surrogate may be a restorative motivation for people’s past events. For example, in Parker’s study, approximately 26% of the mothers who had a previous abortion requested surrogacy through a restorative process mechanism (39). Besides, the Kanefield’s study analyzed psychological compensation as the possibility of achieving “self-coherence” to repair “a damaged sense of self” (65).

Interested in experiencing a different kind of motherhood (attachment or curiosity)
Some researchers argue that “the bond between a pregnant woman and her unborn child is usually an integral and appropriate part of her pregnancy”. The claim that there may be no bond and attachment between the surrogates and the carried fetus and the baby is actually deceiving oneself and they are deceiving themselves by thinking that the child is from another couple.
The idea that she is only a caregiver or she is not a mother, is just a claim. When the surrogate mother realizes that an attachment has developed between her and the child, she becomes sad and depressed after abandoning the baby (66).

Maternal-fetal detachment theory (Baslin-gton’s theory)
Baslington’s theory of “mother-fetal detachment” discusses a framework for understanding how some women abandon their babies in the context of paid surrogacy. Some surrogate mothers learn not to get attached to the unborn child or, if feelings arise, to reduce the inner feelings by diverting emotions towards the couple (67). Of course, studies have also reported that surrogates are not saddened by separation from the infant, but each study emphasizes one or two cases in each sample in which a surrogate reports depression after abandonment (33). Ferolino et al’s study also reported high satisfaction with surrogacy process by surrogate mothers and that they had no psychological problems as a result of abandoning the child. The experiential dimension of giving-up the child is an area that needs more study. The experiences of mothers who performed commercial surrogacy for the first time were as follows: 1) performing an act of altruism, 2) experiencing a different type of motherhood, and 3) promoting a positive body image (36,68). In fact, most surrogates report a happy event and do not report any psychological problems as a result of the abandonment. They report high satisfaction with the process and that they would do surrogacy again. A small percentage of surrogacy arrangements end up in litigations (33). The findings of Jadva et al’s study revealed that surrogate mothers usually do not face major problems in their relationship with the ordering couple, in delivering the baby, or from the reactions of their surroundings. The emotional problems experienced by some surrogate mothers in the weeks after birth appear to have lessened over time. In general, surrogate mothers do not seem to experience psychological problems as a result of accepting surrogacy (68).

Empathy-altruism-spiritualism
In non-commercial surrogacy, it is believed that if a woman has a high altruistic motive, she can establish a “gift relationship” with an infertile couple (69). Research has proved that some surrogate mothers have high emotional empathy, which can help an infertile couple (23). In principle, it is better to change the classification of the motivation of past pregnancy surrogates and consider the bold act of surrogacy as a positive social action, which is a complex combination of internal motives (altruism) and external motives (money) (70). In a qualitative study conducted in Iran in 2022, an important dimension expressed by surrogate mothers is receiving the afterlife reward for their actions. The spiritual aspect of this act was considered very valuable among mothers, which seems to be the result of the social and cultural conditions governing the society. In one case, the surrogate mother stated “as long as they pray for me, that is enough”. In this study, surrogate mothers have a strong financial motivation, but besides this main motivation, they also give priority to the spiritual dimension. According to surrogate mothers, the prayers of infertile couples always accompany them, and they hope that with this benevolent behavior, they will gain God’s satisfaction and God’s servant’s satisfaction in the next world. Surrogate mothers have mentioned the blessedness of the obtained money and believe that this money is so blessed that it can overturn their material life and problems (27). In Ghane’s study, the results showed that surrogate mothers were very satisfied and pleased with their motherhood experience. Experience was considered success and divine grace. Also, “all the participants demonstrated a great desire to make the lives of other families happy. Although their own lives might be full of sadness, they were very happy to give a gift to another family (Feminine Sacrifice). They feel good that they convey the feeling of motherhood to a woman to make her happy and they believe that no woman on earth should be deprived of this beautiful feeling (54).

Spiritualism (commitment and care)
Surrogate mother’s religiosity strengthens the feeling of commitment and care of the fetus. Among the Muslim surrogate mothers, the spiritual dimension of helping others has a special place. The majority of surrogate mothers firmly believe in God and consider themselves committed to the child and God. Therefore, during pregnancy, they pray their daily prayers, recite Ayat al-Kursi (Verse 255 of Surah-e-Baqarah) and Quran every day for the child, and during this period, they strengthen their relationship with God. If the infertile couple insists on paying more attention to the divine laws, the child born of this mother will have a spiritual and God-loving approach. For example, a surrogate mother expressed: “Parents’ hope is in me. I cannot be indifferent at all”. Other surrogate mothers said that they are very committed to the child. They meditate in our behaviors and actions and do not consider any difference with the pregnancy of their own children, because from their point of view, this child is the trust of the people and the hope of a family depends on the fate of this pregnancy (27).

Discussion
The purpose of this study was to investigate the reasons and motivations of surrogate mothers for this appropriate decision and to understand the sense of obligation that these mothers feel in taking care of the child during pregnancy. The importance of socio-cultural background plays a key and decisive role in shaping these motivations and understanding them. Previous researches in this regard have mainly emphasized the motivations and financial reasons among surrogate mothers. In Karandikar et al’s study, the surrogate mothers were illiterate women aged 21 to 30, who had an average of 2 surrogates with financial incentives. Surrogates reported that family and wider community stigma forced them to leave home and relocate after surrogacy (71). In another study in India, commitment to surrogacy was generally determined by the surrogate’s husband. The purpose of their participation was to improve the social and economic status of the family. Surrogate mothers face problems and social condemnations because surrogacy is believed to be associated with extramarital affairs (72). In other studies, practices such as surrogacy in “transition economies” such as India have raised concerns about exploitation, commodification, and social stigma (similar to prostitution and slavery). Also, psychological challenges, violation of physical integrity, and jeopardizing of physical health, freedom (73) and humiliation of mothers have been common (64,74). Stephen Wilkinson has criticized the point of consideration regarding the exploitation and immorality of surrogacy. He believes that if we accept the argument of exploitation for banning surrogacy, the commercial performance of this practice remains very weak. This exploitation can occur in many different ways for poor women in society. Furthermore, the ban may be counterproductive, forcing potential surrogates to do other things that are more exploitative and/or harmful than surrogacy. Therefore, those who oppose exploitation should (rather than trying to stop specific practices like commercial surrogacy) focus on: 
1. Improving the conditions under which paid surrogates “work”. 2. Changing background conditions (in particular, unequal distribution of power and wealth) that create exploitative relations. This researcher believes that surrogacy empowers women and improves their status in society (59).
Other similar studies reported that the experience of being a surrogate mother causes “increased self-confidence” or “increased self-respect” (75,76). Purdy analyzed the ethics and performance of surrogate mothers with a “consequentialist” framework and believes that this practice empowers women and strengthens their position in society by providing a job that is less dangerous and more enjoyable than other jobs. Women are forced to try for more social recognition for reproductive work, and the result will be the birth of children, which, in addition to calm the infertile families, will increase social capital (77). Also, “normal” women are “naturally” prone to emotional bonding, and after giving birth and leaving the baby, they feel they regret and may feel depressed and show somatic or psychological signs of trauma loss (66). 
Some researchers believe that commercial surrogacy can also be an altruistic experience for gestational surrogates. Surrogates can be intrinsically motivated to sympathize with infertile couples. They understand the pain of childlessness. In line with the empathy-altruism hypothesis, if people have strong empathic concerns for others, they will help them regardless of what they can gain (78,79). According to the research findings in Iran, not only surrogate mothers are not an exploitative commodity, but they have altruistic and Godly motives. As a respected person, they give life and meaning to others and are considered to have a kind and helpful personality. There is a feeling of altruism that they can make another person happy and in return get a halal income that is approved by the society. 
Also, the desire to have a child is a natural and God-given instinct, thus it is not a process that can humiliate the surrogate woman. In the deep-rooted Islamic-Iranian culture of our society, the mother has a special and respectable place, and with such a view, surrogates are proud of their act of volunteering as surrogate mothers (27). Of course, the negative aspects are also mentioned, that in some situations, the strong biological relationship between the surrogate mother and the child has been challenging. Also, this pregnancy technology, which was once considered a private and family matter, has been transferred to the public and medical field (80,81). Some surrogate mothers, in addition to earning money, consider the result of their performance to be an important factor in their economic empowerment and independence in their personal and social life (77). On the other hand, the results of surveys on surrogacy show that the majority do not approve of this practice and consider surrogacy to be the least accepted among fertility technologies (33).

Conclusion
The use of surrogacy as a means of parenthood has increased. Most surrogate mothers have positive experiences of surrogacy and do not experience psychological problems caused by carrying an embryo for another person. At a glance surrogacy appears to be an attractive phenomenon especially for poor surrogate mothers and brings the infertile couple to their long-standing desire to have a child.  Financial need and independence, social factors, psychological compensation process and restorative motivations, resolving loneliness due to previous and subsequent failures, and altruism-spiritualism has been among the motivations for accepting the responsibility of the surrogate mother. The absence of a suitable law for surrogate mothers and biological parents (applicants) causes them to be profited and exploited by middlemen and commercial agencies. It is understandable that not having children makes couples frustrated. But in some nations, it causes issues such as national and citizenship problems, problems related to surrogate mothers, infertile couples, and children’s rights. It is suggested that considering the human dignity and vulnerability of the surrogate, it is necessary to observe some basic points: 
One is that the possibility of legal communication after birth between the surrogate mother and the intended family should be investigated.
Second, by examining the nature of international surrogacy, it exacerbates many of the potential commodification and exploitation concerns associated with surrogacy and, therefore, should be avoided.
Third, the governments have prevented the international surrogacy tourism and most of the centers should encourage the selection of the host mother from within the community.
Forth, the issue of new assisted reproductive technologies, including surrogacy, and the increasing development of its use, in addition to legal issues, has various social and cultural dimensions, therefore it is still necessary to carry out broader and deeper social research in the cultural and social dimensions of this phenomenon.

Conflict of Interest 
Authors declare no conflict of interest.

  1. References

    1. Curtis M. Inconceivable: how barriers to infertility treatment for low-income women amount to reproductive oppression. Georget J Poverty Law Policy 2017;25(2):323-42. https://www.law.georgetown.edu/poverty-journal/in-print/volume-25-number-2-winter-2018/inconceivable-how-barriers-to-infertility-treatment-for-low-income-women-amount-to-reproductive-oppression/
    2. Ombelet W, Cooke I, Dyer S, Serour G, Devroey P. Infertility and the provision of infertility medical services in developing countries. Hum Reprod Update 2008;14(6):605-21. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18820005/
    3. Tabong PT-N, Adongo PB. Understanding the social meaning of infertility and childbearing: a qualitative study of the perception of childbearing and childlessness in Northern Ghana. PLoS One 2013;8(1):e54429. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23342158/
    4. Direkvand Moghadam A, Delpisheh A, Sayehmiri K. [The prevalence of infertility in Iran, a systematic review.] Iran J Obstet Gynecol Infertil 2013;16(81):1-7. Persian. https://ijogi.mums.ac.ir/article_2231_82f90014bfc4ad5f22d68274c3e9eb84.pdf?lang=en
    5. Imannezhad S, Mirzaei M, Khodadadi B, Heydari O, Dehghani N. Prevalence of infertility among Iranian women: an overview of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Health Providers 2024 Jun 1;4(1):1-8. https://www.health-providers.ir/article_193681.html
    6. Fahami F, Hosseini Ghouchani S, Ehsanpour S, Zargham A. [Women’s lived experiences of female infertility.] Iran J Obstet Gynecol Infertil 2010;13(4):45-53. Persian. Available from: https://sid.ir/paper/64751/en
    7. Inhorn MC, Birenbaum-Carmeli D, Tremayne S, Gürtin ZB. Assisted reproduction and Middle East kinship: A regional and religious comparison. Reprod Biomed Soc Online 2017;4:41-51. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29774265/
    8. Islam S, Nordin RB, Bin Shamsuddin AR, Mohd nor HB, Al-Mahmood AK. Ethics of surrogacy: a comparative study of Western secular and islamic bioethics. J IMA 2013 Apr 13;44(1):44-1-5920. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23864994/
    9. Mosalanejad L, Parandavar N, Abdollahifard S. Barriers to infertility treatment: an integrated study. Glob J Health Sci 2013 Nov 25;6(1):181-91. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24373278/

    10.Boivin J, Oguz M, Duong M, Cooper O, Filipenko D, Markert M, et al. Emotional reactions to infertility diagnosis: thematic and natural language processing analyses of the 1000 Dreams survey. Reprod Biomed Online 2023 Feb;46(2):399-409. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36463078/

    11.Kobori Y. Home testing for male factor infertility: a review of current options. Fertil Steril 2019;111(5):864-70. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30922654/

    12.Mitchell A, Fantasia HC. Understanding the effect of obesity on fertility among reproductive-age women. Nurs Womens Health 2016;20:368-76. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27520601/

    13.de Waal E, McCarrey JR. Effects of exogenous endocrine stimulation on epigenetic programming of the female germline genome. Anim Reprod 2018;7(3):154-154. https://www.animal-reproduction.org/article/5b5a6067f7783717068b4741

    1. Kessler LM, Craig BM, Plosker SM, Reed DR, Quinn GP. Infertility evaluation and treatment among women in the United States. Fertil Steril 2013;100(4):1025-32. e2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23849845/
    2. Robertson JA. Other women’s wombs: uterus transplants and gestational surrogacy. J Law Biosci 2016;3(1):68-86. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27774233/
    3. Patel NH, Jadeja YD, Bhadarka HK, Patel MN, Patel NH, Sodagar NR. Insight into different aspects of surrogacy practices. J Hum Reprod Sci 2018;11(3):212. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30568349/
    4. Herweck A, DeSantis C, Shandley LM, Kawwass JF, Hipp HS. International gestational surrogacy in the United States, 2014-2020. Fertil Steril 2024 Apr;121(4):622-30. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38176517/
    5. Montebruno P. Essays in economic geography: school vouchers, student riots and maternal surrogacy [Thesis]. [UK]: The London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE); 2016. 239 p.

    19.Golombok S, Murray C, Jadva V, MacCallum F, Lycett E. Families created through surrogacy arrangements: parent-child relationships in the 1st year of life. Dev Psychol 2004 May;40(3):400-11. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15122966/

    1. Serour GI. Ethical issues in human reproduction: Islamic perspectives. Gynecol Endocrinol 2013 Nov;29(11):949-52. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24004295/
    2. Samani RO, Moalem MR, Merghati ST, Alizadeh L. Debate in embryo donation: embryo donation or both-gamete donation? Reprod Biomed Online 2009;19(Suppl 1):29-33. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19622248/

    22.Kutty A. Does Islam allow ‘surrogate motherhood’? Doha, Qatar: Islamonline.net; [Updated 2007-Jan-7; Accessed 2013-Apr-8]. http://bit.ly/ZJv6bp.

    23.Patel NH, Jadeja YD, Bhadarka HK, Patel MN, Patel NH, Sodagar NR. Insight into different aspects of surrogacy practices. J Hum Reprod Sci 2018 Jul-Sep;11(3):212-218. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30568349/

    1. Saxena P, Mishra A, Malik S. Surrogacy: ethical and legal issues. Indian J Community Med 2012 Oct;37(4):211-3. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23293432/

    25.Bhatia K, Martindale EA, Rustamov O, Nysenbaum AM. Surrogate pregnancy: an essential guide for clinicians. Obstet Gynecol 2009;11:49-54. https://obgyn.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1576/toag.11.1.49.27468

    26.Dashtizadeh P, Mazloom Rahni A, Rajabzadeh A. Legal and ethical challenges of surrogacy contracts in Iranian judicial and medical system. Health Spiritual Med Ethic 2019;6(3):53-60. http://jhsme.muq.ac.ir/article-1-324-en.html

    1. Ghane-Mokhallesouni Z, Razeghi-Nasrabad HB, Askari-Nodoushan A, Kalate Sadati A. Surrogate mothers, decision motivations and sense of commitment: a grounded theory. J Population Assoc Iran 2022;16(31):97-131. https://www.jpaiassoc.ir/article_249726.html?lang=en.

    28.Söderström-Anttila V, Wennerholm UB, Loft A, Pinborg A, Aittomäki K, Romundstad LB, et al. Surrogacy: outcomes for surrogate mothers, children and the resulting families—a systematic review. Hum Reprod Update 2016;22(2):260-76. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26454266/

    29.Dadkhah N, Asgari Khanqah A, Basri A, Miraskandari F. [Investigating surrogate mothers’ lived experience of renting a womb (case study: surrogate mothers in Tehran)]. Women’s Dev Politics 2019;18(4):557-78. Persian.

    30.Garmaroudi S. [Gestational Surrogacy in Iran.] J Reprod Infertil 2008;9(1):50-64. Persian. magiran.com/p551612

    1. Sadeghi H, yazdkhasti B, Malekahmadi H, Abdellahi A. Phenomenological experience of the surrogate mothers in renting wombs. Woman Fam Stud 2014;1(2):401-21. magiran.com/p1292318
    2. Berend, Z. The romance of surrogacy. Sociol Forum 2012;27:913-36. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1573-7861.2012.01362.x
    3. Teman E. The social construction of surrogacy research: an anthropological critique of the psychosocial scholarship on surrogate motherhood. Soc Sci Med 2008 Oct;67(7):1104-12. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18573577/
    4. Laufer-Ukeles P. Mothering for money: regulating commercial intimacy. Indiana Law J 2013;88(4)1223-78. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2263839
    5. Arvidsson A, Vauquline P, Johnsdotter S, Essén B. Surrogate mother–praiseworthy or stigmatized: a qualitative study on perceptions of surrogacy in Assam, India. Glob Health Action 2017;10(1):1328890. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28604252/
    6. Ferolino AP, Camposo MAD, Estaño KCL, Tacbobo JMR. Mothers for others: an interpretative phenomenological analysis of gestational surrogates’ child relinquishment experiences. J Patient Exp 2020;7(6):1336-40. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33457584/
    7. Ahmadi A, Bamdad S. Assisted reproductive technologies and the Iranian community attitude towards infertility. Hum Fertil (Camb) 2017;20(3):204-11. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28635408/
    8. Karandikar S, Gezinski LB, Carter JR, Kaloga M. Economic necessity or noble cause? A qualitative study exploring motivations for gestational surrogacy in Gujarat, India. Affilia 2014;29(2):224-36. DOI: 10.1177/0886109913516455.
    9. Imrie S, Jadva V. The long-term experiences of surrogates: relationships and contact with surrogacy families in genetic and gestational surrogacy arrangements. Reprod Biomed Online 2014;29(4):424-35. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25131555/
    10. Ruiz-Robledillo N, Moya-Albiol L. Gestational surrogacy: psychosocial aspects. Psychosoc Interv 2016;25(3):187-93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psi.2016.05.001
    11. Berend Z. The social context for surrogates’ motivations and satisfaction. Reprod Biomed Online 2014;29(4):399-401. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25129693/
    12. Bromfield NF. “Surrogacy has been one of the most rewarding experiences in my life”: A content analysis of blogs by US commercial gestational surrogates. IJFAB: Int J Feminist Approach Bioethics 2016;9(1):192-217. DOI:10.3138/ijfab.9.1.192
    13. Teman E. Birthing a mother: the surrogate body and the pregnant self. 1st ed. California: University of California Press; 2010. 384 p.
    14. Whittaker A, Inhorn, M C, & Shenfield F. Globalised quests for assisted conception: Reproductive travel for infertility and involuntary childlessness. Glob Public Health 2019;14(12):1669-88. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31204900/
    15. Asiimwe S, Osingada CP, Mbalinda SN, Muyingo M, Ayebare E, Namutebi M, et al. Women’s experiences of living with involuntary childlessness in Uganda: a qualitative phenomenological study. BMC Women’s Health 2022 Dec 19;22(1):532. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36536395/
    16. Payne N, Seenan S, van den Akker O. Experiences of involuntary childlessness and treatment in the UK: what has changed in 20 years? Hum Fertil (Camb) 2021 Dec;24(5):333-40. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31707869/
    17. Naik Africawala A, Kapadia S. Women’s control over decision to participate in surrogacy: Experiences of surrogate mothers in Gujarat. J Bioeth Inq 2019;16:501-14. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31399942/
    18. Peng L. Surrogate mothers: an exploration of the empirical and the normative. J Gender Soc Policy Law 2012;21:555. https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1610&context=jgspl
    19. Khalaf ZF, Shafiabadi A, Tarahomi M. Psychological aspects of surrogate motherhood. Jo Reprod Infertil 2008;9(1). https://www.jri.ir/article/305
    20. Dadkhah N, Asgari Khanghah A, Baseri A, Mireskandari F. [Surrogacy culture in the Iranian society of Tehran.] Social Psychol Stud Women 2020;63(18):111-52. Persian. https://ensani.ir/file/download/article/1615376866-9830-99-2-4.pdf
    21. Pashmi M, Sadegh Tabatabaie S M, Ahmadi S A. [Evaluating the experiences of surrogate and intended mothers in terms of surrogacy in Isfahan.] IJRM 2010;8(1):33-40. Persian.
      http://ijrm.ir/article-1-165-en.html
    22. Zandi M, Vanaki Z, Shiva M, Mohammadi E. Nine centuries waiting: the experiences of Iranians surrogacy commissioning mothers. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res 2014;19(3):224-32. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24949058/
    23. Golboni F, Jalali A, Dinmohammadi M, Taghizadeh Z, Nouri P, Salahsoor MR. Iranian model of decision making to use surrogacy: a grounded theory study. Health Care Women Int 2020;41(7):853-65. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32357079/
    24. Ghane-Mokhallesouni Z, Askari-Nodoushan A, Nasrabad HBR, Sadati AK, Firouzabadi RD. Representation of a ‘positive experience’ of surrogacy in Yazd, Iran: a qualitative study. Int J Reprod Biomed 2022;20(9):769-778. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36340669/
    25. Shayestefar M, Abedi H. Leading factors to surrogacy from pregnant surrogate mothers’ vantage point: a qualitative research. Int J Women’s Health Reprod Sci 2017:97-102. https://ijwhr.net/pdf/pdf_IJWHR_159.pdf
    26. Mahmoodian H, Saboorian N, Nabeiei P. [Attitudes of infertile women towards surrogacy in Infertility Clinics of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences.] Sadra Med J 2017;5(3):131-40. Persian. https://smsj.sums.ac.ir/article_43927.html?lang=en
    27. Musavi S, Abdolahi HM, Ghojazadeh M, Farhangi MA, Nikniaz Z, Nikniaz L. Infertile women’s opinion concerning gestational surrogacy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Iran J Public Health 2020;49(8):1432. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33083319/
    28. Hadizadeh-Talasaz F, Latifnejad Roudsari R, Simbar M. Decision for disclosure: the experiences of Iranian infertile couples undergoing assisted reproductive donation procedures. Hum Fertil (Camb) 2015;18(4):265-75. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26428703/
    29. Wilkinson S. The exploitation argument against commercial surrogacy. Bioethics 2003 Apr;17(2):169-87. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12812183/
    30. Vertommen S, Barbagallo C. The in/visible wombs of the market: the dialectics of waged and unwaged reproductive labour in the global surrogacy industry. Rev Int Political Economy 2022;29(6):1945-66. https://biblio.ugent.be/publication/8691774
    31. Sharma RS. Social, ethical, medical & legal aspects of surrogacy: an Indian scenario. The Indian J Med Res 2014;140(Suppl 1):S13. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25673533/
    32. Bhadaraka K. The last ray of hope: surrogate mother-the reality. [Dissertation]. [India]: Anand Surrogate Trust; 2009.
    33. Jadva V, Murray C, Lycett E, MacCallum F, Golombok S. Surrogacy: the experiences of surrogate mothers. Hum Reprod 2003 Oct;18(10):2196-204. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14507844/
    34. Parker PJ. Motivation of surrogate mothers: initial findings. Am J Psychiatry 1983 Jan;140(1):117-8. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6847974/
    35. Kanefield L. The reparative motive in surrogate mothers. Adoption Quarterly 1999;2(4):5-19. https://doi.org/10.1300/J145v02n04_02
    36. van Zyl L, van Niekerk A. Interpretations, perspectives and intentions in surrogate motherhood. J Med Ethics 2000 ;26(5):404-9. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11055048/

    67.Baslington H. The social organization of surrogacy: relinquishing a baby and the role of payment in the psychological detachment process. J Health Psychol 2002 Jan;7(1):57-71. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22114227/

    1. Jadva V, Imrie S. Children of surrogate mothers: psychological well-being, family relationships and experiences of surrogacy. Hum Reprod 2014;29(1):90-6. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24256993/
    2. Raymond JG. Reproductive gifts and gift giving: the altruistic woman. Hastings Cent Rep 1990 Nov-Dec;20(6):7-11. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2283292/
    3. Lorenceau E, Mazzucca L, Tisseron S, Pizitz T. A cross-cultural study on surrogate mother’s empathy and maternal–foetal attachment. Women Birth 2015; 28:154–9. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25487002/

    71.Karandikar S, Gezinski L B, Carter J R, & Kaloga M. Economic necessity or noble cause? A qualitative study exploring motivations for gestational surrogacy in Gujarat, India. Affilia 2014;29(2):224-36. https://doi.org/10.1177/0886109913516455

    72.Rozée V, Unisa S, de La Rochebrochard E. The social paradoxes of commercial surrogacy in developing countries: India before the new law of 2018. BMC Womens Health 2020 Oct 15;20(1):234. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33059640/

    73.Saravanan, S. Humanitarian’thresholds of the fundamental feminist ideologies: evidence from surrogacy arrangements in India. AnALize: Revista Studii Feministe 2016;6(20):66-88. https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=469880

    1. Rothman, B. K. The Legacy of Patriarchy as Context for Surrogacy: Or Why Are We Quibbling Over This? Am J Bioeth 2014;14(5):36-7. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24766120/
    2. Yee S, Goodman CV, Librach CL. Determinants of gestational surrogates’ satisfaction in relation to the characteristics of surrogacy cases. Reprod Biomed Online 2019 Aug;39(2):249-61. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31182357/

    76.Yau A, Friedlander RL, Petrini A, Holt MC, White DE, Shin J, et al. Medical and mental health implications of gestational surrogacy. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2021 Sep;225(3):264-9. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33839094/

    77.Purdy LM. Surrogate mothering: exploitation or empowerment? Bioethics 1989 Jan;3(1):18-34. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11650110/

    1. Batson CD. Prosocial motives, emotions, and behavior: the better angels of our nature. 1st ed. American Psychological Association; 2010. Empathy-induced altruistic motivation; pp. 15–34. Available: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2009-08941-001
    2. Batson CD, Eklund JH, Chermok VL, Hoyt JL, Ortiz BG. An additional antecedent of empathic concern: valuing the welfare of the person in need. J Pers Soc Psychol 2007 Jul;93(1):65-74. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17605589/
    3. Teman E, Berend Z. Surrogacy as a family project: How surrogates articulate familial identity and belonging. J Fam Issues 2021;42(6):1143-65. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192513X20944527
    4. Afshani SA, Abdoli AM, Hashempour M, Baghbeheshti M, Zolfaghari M. The attitudes of infertile couples towards assisted reproductive techniques in Yazd, Iran: a cross sectional study in 2014. Int J Reprod Biomed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28066835/